johnh wrote:Frankie wrote:johnh wrote:National Service should be brought back asap - 2 years from age 18. Looking back, it was one of the best things that happened to me in my life. Instilled discipline, responsibility, respect for others and respect for oneself. I don't think you will find an ex National Serviceman who will disagree. If you do, they will probably be in a minority of one! There were the odd ones who genuinely had a raw deal, particularly those who were 'deferred' - University students etc., and who went in in their early 20's. Always felt sorry for them as they didn't seem to fit in.
I don't agree at all. The world has changed. Young people have changed, pacifism is much wider spread these days thankfully. This would seriously affect the mental health of so many young people, to be forced into something they don't agree with. Young people have been increasingly neglected over the last decade or so. Many are further and further alienated in our society.
Perhaps you could consider that all young people should be supported into further education, vocational training or armed forces training if they so wish, so they can find their own version of self-worth, responsibility and contribution to society. What about community work? There is so much deprivation and decay in so many communities. This would perhaps be more worth while and a much wider scoped experience for young people, to learn respect for their world.
99.9% of National Service recruits didn't want to go in either. Didn''t do their mental health any harm though, in fact, considerably strengthened it.
Can agree in part to what you are both saying here but the one thing I do believe is the government has a duty to its citizens to provide opportunity and not a living.
To explain my thoughts further because this is a very significant issue regarding young people.
School leavers should have good opportunities whether that is further education such as Universities or other areas. I actually believe too many are directed towards University education when we need a return to technical colleges where they can learn trades. The country actually needs Plumbers, Joiners, Builders, Electricians, car mechanics, nurses, agriculture etc among many other things (I'm sure we can all add).
The biggest mistakes the country has made in the last 50 years is the obsession everyone needs to go to Uni to be educated, no most need to start a career path as soon as they finish School. The most important thing to learn for school leavers is how to get out of bed in a morning.
Of course learning a trade also teaches discipline as you are reliant on others to teach you.
As a country we need to be able feed ourselves and build for our needs and look after each other.
Of course its not been helped by industry been run down and cheap imports, sad to say it but the government and Unions both have to share some of the blame for this. Not a blame game though the question is about looking forward and building a better place for everyone.
Of course if then there is nothing for a young person or they are incapable of bettering themselves when the opportunity is there then i will go along with John and a couple of years of tough discipline serving Her Majesty would do no harm at all.
I'm not political left or right I try to look at all situations and how they could be better and base opinion on that, wish more would do rather than the i swing to the left so the right are always wrong or vice versa i voted tory so the socialists must be wrong.
My thoughts are work together for a better world, we need the buisiness men to provide the work and the workers to provide the skills. What we don't need is the selfish spongers that are not prepared to put anything in. is it really too much to ask.
Keep your face always toward the sunshine - and shadows will fall behind you.