Page 1 of 3

Commentators

PostPosted: 29 Jul 2018, 07:20
by NottinghamWhite
These so called experts are they really necessary in sport today ? It really has, particularly on Sky become a job for the boys & these days girls. At a game of cricket there can be as many as 8 all doing 30 minute stints telling us what we've already just watched. All of these ' experts ' will be commanding decent salaries plus travelling the world by first class air travel & 5* hotels to stay in. Am I just becoming a miserable old git or do you agree too many of 'em ?

Re: Commentators

PostPosted: 29 Jul 2018, 07:53
by Selby White
Can't stand most of them total waste of money.

That makes two of us in the miserable old gits club.

Re: Commentators

PostPosted: 29 Jul 2018, 07:59
by Selby White
A few years back a mate of mine was in the arrivals security queue at O'Hare airport (Chicago) just before the Ryder Cup.

It's was taking well over an hour to get through when John Inverdale and his cronies arrived and walked to the front of the queue.
They flashed their Press ID's only to be told by one of the American security officers where the back of the queue was.

Apparently people in the queue cheered the security man and the look on their faces was priceless.

Re: Commentators

PostPosted: 29 Jul 2018, 08:32
by Another Northern Soul
Are you saying commentators aren't needed for televised sport or just the ones that get on your wicks?

:)

Re: Commentators

PostPosted: 29 Jul 2018, 08:39
by NottinghamWhite
Another Northern Soul wrote:Are you saying commentators aren't needed for televised sport or just the ones that get on your wicks?

:)



Not saying commentators aren't needed it's just the sheer number who are on the payroll. At the recent World Cup you'd have 2 commentating on the game, 1 pitch side & up to 4 in the studio. It's even worse at cricket there can be as many as 8 all doing 20 minute stints. Plus all the analysis is it needed ? Also in football the jobs seem open to only Man U or Liverpool players is there no one else, I know there are exceptions but they're clearly the favoured ones.

Re: Commentators

PostPosted: 29 Jul 2018, 09:14
by ChilwellWhite
I tend to switch the sound off at halftime during the football rather than listen to them prattling on.

Re: Commentators

PostPosted: 29 Jul 2018, 09:15
by Davycc
Personally I don't mind them as at half time I usually go put the kettle on. Agree though that maybe one guest "pro" in the studio would be enough.

Re: Commentators

PostPosted: 29 Jul 2018, 09:22
by rigger
I think it all depends on who they are but there's no need for more than two.
The ITV pundits were largely very good at the World Cup but there were simply too many, especially with the ad breaks interrupting any flow they got going.
I'd rather watch Bilic and Keane or Dixon and O'Neill for the entire half time segment than sit through Mark Pougatch squeezing them all for a series of bullet points every time ...

Re: Commentators

PostPosted: 29 Jul 2018, 09:23
by Barlow Boy
I’ve not thought about the actual numbers of commentators, but the great Sid Waddell was my personal favourite, and whilst he’s from the dark side, I do like Bumble at the cricket.

Re: Commentators

PostPosted: 29 Jul 2018, 09:28
by Another Northern Soul
Like a smelly trump in a lift, I shall just leave this here:

I don't like female commentary on men's football.

Tin hat on and I'm OUTTA here :D